Lord scarman was appointed by then home secretary william whitelaw to hold a local inquiry on 14 april. Of course, political moments do not emerge from nowhere and reference to the wider context remains central to understanding a particular period. Lord scarman, a former high court judge and lord of appeal, will be best remembered for the four major inquiries he conducted into violent incidents of british public life. Racial disadvantage is a fact of current british 233 234 john benyon life, wrote lord scarman, and a significant factor in the causation of the riots scarman, 9. The report which is before your lordships is in fact a profoundly important document for which parliament and, indeed, the whole nation must be tremendously grateful to the noble and learned lord, lord scarman, who has done his work so thoroughly and so competently in the short span of time that has been available to him since he was asked to. He was appointed head of the law commission from 1965 to 1973, during. Essays reflecting on lord scarmans report, the riots, and their aftermath by john benyon and a great selection of related books, art and collectibles available now at. Scarman lecture 2015 as delivered amazon web services. He served in the lords until his retirement in 1986. Lord scarmans report1 on the 1981 disorders in brixton and elsewhere was described as an historic document and received. Leslie scarman, chairman of the law commission 196573, who was later thrust into the public eye for his 1981 inquiry into the brixton riots, stood out in his generation as the model judge. It identified complex political, social and economic factors that created a disposition towards violent protest, but did not explicitly condemn police racism and denied that institutional racism even existed.
Scarman, a law lord, had a reputation for compassion, learning, and fair mindedness and had previously carried out similar types of inquiries into the 1969. Urgent action is required but above all the scarman report was a call for actiona call echoed by the contributors to this book. The scarman report hansard, 25 november 1981 parliament. Inquiry into the 1981 brixton disturbances scarman. Lord scarman was also empowered with making recommendations in how to prevent further disorder in the future. I accepted the need to develop formal arrangements in every police force area for consultation. The report ranges more widely, and goes on to discuss those factors which, in lord scarmans view, led to the disorders. Lord scarman was appointed by then home secretary william whitelaw on 14 april 1981 two days after the rioting ended to hold the enquiry into the riots. Edition notes report of an inquiry by the right honourable the lord scarman. Lord scarman stated that complex political, social and economic factors created a. Lord scarman is the final part of his report made a number of findings and recommendations and i will go through them now. Lord scarman author of the brixton disorders, april 1012. This file may not be suitable for users of assistive technology.
It was the first law reform project i worked on and infused in me a permanent taste for big, ambitious law reform. Part 2a police and community relations the scarman. The lord scarman, who died on wednesday aged 93, was one of the finest lawyers of the postwar era. The brixton disorders 1012 april 1981 pelican new ed by scarman, george isbn. Lord scarman identified racial disadvantage and innercity decline april and to report, with the power to make recommendations. This report had been compiled following a series of evidence hearings from community members, police officers and other relevant persons. Lord justice scarman was appointed by the home secretary to inquire urgently into the serious disorder in brixton on 1012 april 1981 and to report, with the power to make recommendations. It identified complex political, social and economic factors that created a disposition towards violent protest, but did not explicitly condemn police racism. When i presented the report to parliament, i accepted the general principles that it set out for policing policy.
My lords, i beg leave to ask the question standing in my name on the order paper. This text is organized into five parts encompassing 22 chapters. The first, into the troubles in belfast and londonderry in 1969, took two years, and the 250page report found that there was no evidence of any plans for an armed insurrection. Under the terms of the licence agreement, an individual user may print out a pdf of a single entry from a reference work in or for. The backdrop is of course the demise of the keynesian welfare state and the harsh realities of neoliberalism. It is just 15 days since lord scarmans report was published and was welcomed on both sides of the house.
The brixton disorders, 1012 april, 1981 leslie george scarman tim 2012 30 years after brixton, what would lord scarman have made of the 2011 riots guardian. Home housing important improve incident independent injured inner city inquiry inspector involved lack lambeth leaders liaison london lord matters meeting metropolitan police necessary offence operations paragraphs particular party patrol phase police authorities police. In so far as the report deals with the other matters, the report. My lords, during the weekend of 10th12th april last year, there occurred riots in brixton which involved violence and disorder unparalleled this century.
Following the brixton disorders of april 1981 the home secretary, william whitelaw, appointed lord scarman to undertake an investigation into. The scarman report was released in november 1981 and made very interesting reading. Scarman described this as a spontaneous act of defiant aggression by young men who felt themselves hunted by a hostile police force scarman, 3. Violence and civil disturbances in northern ireland. Understanding the riots centre for crime and justice. The scarman report and explanations of riots sciencedirect. The first parts explore the political agenda of the brixton riot and lord scarmans report, explanations, images and impact of.
My lords, with the leave of your lordships, i will now repeat a statement being made in another place by. The scarman report was published on 25 november 1981. The preface is the transcript of a talk given by lord scarman in the television series opinions, produced by panoptic and broadcast on channel 4 in february 1986 t. This report, the brixton disorders, april 1012 1981. He sees then as stemming from a breakdown in confidence between the police and the coloured community, against a background of urban deprivation, racial disadvantage and a rising level of street crime.
My lords, during the weekend of 10th12th april last year, there occurred riots in brixton which involved violence and. The scarman report highlighted problems of racial disadvantage and innercity decline, warning that urgent action was needed to prevent racial disadvantage becoming an endemic, ineradicable disease threatening the very. The stephen lawrence inquiry report of an inquiry by sir william macpherson of cluny advised by tom cook, the right reverend dr john sentamu, dr richard stone presented to parliament by the secretary of state for the home department by command of her majesty. The report of the inquiry into the murder of black teenager stephen lawrence, to be published next week, is the most significant comment on police and the community since the scarman report into. Brixton has many features of a decaying inner city area. I am very glad it has been possible to provide a day for this debate so soon. Report to the right honourable william whitelaw, secretary of state for the home department, on the brixton disorders of.
Lord scarmans perceptive analysis of the british police was provoked, not by an accumulation of sociological data or any other body of researched evidence. Meanwhile the response has shifted from attempts symbolised by lord scarmans report on the brixton riots of 1981 to reintegrate the rioters and their communities into what remained of welfare citizenship to a reinforced criminalisation of a dysfunctional population. In so far as the report deals with the acts of violence and civil disturbance occurring in londonderry, belfast and armagh, it is the report of all three of us and the findings are those of the tribunal of three. The lord scarman report itemized and stressed particular issues that arose from the brixton disorders. The terms of reference for the enquiry were to inquire urgently into the serious disorder in. The scarman report 1981, which resulted from an official inquiry into rioting in the brixton neighbourhood of london, concluded that police had become too remote from their communities, that local citizens should have more input into police policy making, and that police tactics should be more. Lord scarman stated that complex political, social and economic factors created a disposition towards violent protest.
Lord belstead rose to move, that this house takes notes of the report on the brixton disorders, 10th12th april 1981 cmnd. The scarman report 30 years on nothing like the sun. The scarman report and explanations of riots 29 themselves. Everyday low prices and free delivery on eligible orders. Lord scarman is the author of the brixton disorders, april 1012, 1981 5. Essays reflecting on lord scarmans report, the riots and their aftermath edited by john benyon. The oxford companion to black british history authors. Its terms of reference were to inquire urgently into the serious disorder in brixton on 1012 april 1981 and to report, with the power to make recommendations. Following the brixton disorders of april 1981 the home secretary, william whitelaw, appointed lord scarman to undertake an investigation into the causes of the disturbances. On 30 september 1977, scarman was made a lord of appeal in ordinary, becoming baron scarman, of quatt in the county of shropshire. The report of the noble and learned lord, lord scarman, on the brixton disorders of april 1981 was dated 30th october last, almost exactly a year ago. The scarman report was commissioned by the uk government following the 1981 brixton riots. Understanding the riots centre for crime and justice studies.
644 1430 1438 1538 786 1428 788 1338 274 734 626 436 713 1022 833 199 1600 942 210 897 970 781 1179 188 1225 1196 131 442 76 100 185 1189